Why Ping-Pong Handovers Are Bad and How LTE Prevents Them

What’s the Technical Problem?

In LTE mobility, the UE (user equipment) constantly measures signal conditions (RSRP/RSRQ) of the serving cell and neighboring cells. If a neighbor cell becomes better, the UE may trigger a handover , but what if the difference is temporary or marginal?

That’s when ping-pong handovers occur - rapid back-and-forth switching between two cells, which creates:

:no_entry_sign: Increased signaling overhead
:battery: Faster battery drain
:chart_with_downwards_trend: Call drops or interrupted sessions
:bar_chart: Poor KPIs like high HOF (handover failure) or RLF (radio link failure)

:open_book: LTE Theory: How It Avoids Ping-Pong
LTE standards (3GPP) introduced smart mechanisms to stabilize handover decisions, particularly for Event A3, which compares neighbor vs serving cell.

Here are the key components:

:white_check_mark: 1. Hysteresis (Q_hyst)
A positive offset (e.g., 3 dB) added to the serving cell RSRP so that the neighbor must be significantly better.
:repeat: Prevents handover unless the improvement is real and sustainable.

:white_check_mark: 2. Time-To-Trigger (TTT)
A timer (e.g., 320 ms to 512 ms) that must expire while conditions remain valid before triggering a measurement report.
:hourglass_flowing_sand: Helps avoid triggering for brief signal spikes.

:white_check_mark: 3. Filtering (Layer 3)
Applies moving average filters (e.g., filter coefficient 5) to smooth out fast fading effects in RSRP/RSRQ readings.
:control_knobs: Reduces short-term signal noise that might cause false handovers.

Here’s a graph that visualizes RSRP trends for Serving and Neighbor Cells along with the A3 event triggering logic, including:

:chart_with_downwards_trend: Serving Cell RSRP (blue line)
:chart_with_upwards_trend: Neighbor Cell RSRP (orange line)
:white_check_mark: Handover Trigger Zone (green shaded area) where the neighbor RSRP exceeds the serving cell RSRP by an offset (e.g., 3 dB)
:green_square: Dashed green line = “Serving RSRP + Offset” to indicate the handover threshold

:bar_chart:Visual Elements:
Two LTE towers (Cell A and Cell B)
A phone oscillating rapidly (Without Hysteresis/TTT)
A calm, stable handover only after sustained improvement (With Hysteresis + TTT)

:pushpin: Optimization Tip for Engineers:
In urban areas with dense cell grids, set a higher TTT + moderate hysteresis (e.g., 320ms + 3dB).
On highways, consider slightly lower TTT to react faster to degradation.

LinkedIn: :point_down: