Comparison between Mentum and Atoll

Does anyone have any experience with Mentum planet tool?

image

1 Like

Yes, I have hands-on experience.

Anyone can share correlation between Aster Model (Atoll) and P3M model (Mentum)?
I understand the linear losses in Atoll are tunable, but losses P3M is a blackbox.

Any support in sharing some info is appreciated. Thanks.

In planet general model (2D), we had K1 and K2 to tune to bring down RMS and STD.
What are the coefficients of P3M (3D) model?

yes i am

in P3M there is no K1,K2,etc. but there are clutter loss, outer wall loss, penetration loss, rain attenuation, atmospheric attenuation. P3M attended for Urban environment